Monday, December 04, 2006

Derridean, my dear Watson [Winston?]

Apologies, again.

Just thinking about what Derrida said during the movie this morning, about the philosopher who reads intently a few paragraphs being a better biographer than someone who knows the whole story. Went home and dug out my copy of George Orwell's Nineteen Eighty-Four with the foreword from Thomas Pynchon (Yeah, I'm enough of a nerd that I asked for this specific edition for Christmas last year, even though I think it was teetering on the edge of going out of print.)


"... Despite his admiration for them as a force for salvation, and his faith in their eventual triumph, Winston Smith doesn't seem to know any proles himself - his only personal contact, and that is indirect, is with the lady singing outside the room in back of the antique shop where he and Julia have found their lovers' refuge. 'The tune had been haunting London for weeks past. It was one of countless similar songs published for the benefit of the proles by a sub-section of the Music Department.' By Winston's Inner Party poetic standards, the tune is 'driveling,' 'dreadful rubbish.' But Orwell quotes it three times, almost word for word. Is something else going on? One cannot be sure - one likes to imagine that Orwell, a songwriter in disguise who loved writing verse that rhymed and had a beat, also came up with an actual melody for this lyric, and that while he was writing 1984 he went around humming or whistling it, perhaps for days on end, driving those in his vicinity crazy. His own artistic judgements were not those of Winston Smith, a bourgeois of the late '40s projected into the future. Orwell enjoyed what we now call pop culture - his allegiance, in music as in politics, belong to the people." (Orwell, xviii-xix)
So. Do they still give out trophies for being a dork?

No comments: